Fay Blood trait question

[Mikado]

This is very munchkinly and I would never do or allow someone to do this but I feel the need to ask anyway.

I was making a Human Sword-Singer (fay blood trait) and came up with this question.

If a person selects the "Fay Blood" trait and gets "Essence of the Earth" Elf trait (the immortal trait), which is different from the regular immortal trait, do they use the Elf age Stat pool or the human age Stat pool?

If for some odd reason a GM would allow a player to use the elf stats the player could make... well... something really bad...

[luke]

It's pretty clear in the rules, you get stat points based on your born LPs and the lifepaths you choose from.

But sometimes it can be fun to monkey around with characters, using different age charts for different lifepath sets.

I've got to post my Lost Atlantean goblin. I used the Orc age charts and took Lost Atlantean lifepaths. He came out great!

-Luke

[Mikado]

Well, your Lost Atlantean threw me off...

Immortal
The Lost Atlantean cannot die from age or sickness, however age does weigh upon him to some degree. Rather than enjoying eternal youth like the elves, the Lost Atlantean simply stops aging when other men would die. Thus he will reach an age of frailty and white hair, but he may maintain (or regain) his strength through a vigorous lifestyle. Use the standard Age and Stat Pool Chart for men for the Lost Atlantean.

So it would figure that someone with elf immortality would use the elf age and stat pool.

I have no idea why I'm arguing this...